This Lawyer Grew Up in Beverly Hills. She Won’t Pretend She Gets It

How does a lawyer who grew up Beverly Hills earn the trust of someone whose life looks nothing like hers? Brooklyn public defender Sydney Siegel starts by acknowledging the distance. She treats clients as equals, makes clear that she works for them, and refuses to pretend she understands experiences she has never lived.

Sydney talks about about criminal defense, client relationships, ambition, and the parts of yourself that don’t fit a conventional legal career. She has competed in Division I track at Columbia, attended Brooklyn Law School, and appeared on Survivor and The Challenge. But some of her most revealing experiences happen far from television, in conversations with people facing criminal charges.

Before becoming a public defender, Sydney was fascinated by crime and imagined defense work very differently. Meeting clients challenged those assumptions. A complaint could describe something disturbing, while a conversation with the person accused could reveal circumstances the paperwork never captured. She explains how that experience changed her understanding of the work, from representing someone she had already judged to understanding the person whose rights she was responsible for protecting.

That shift also changed how she viewed procedural victories. Sydney discusses learning to see discovery demands and procedural challenges as part of holding the prosecution accountable. For young lawyers entering criminal practice, it is a candid account of how the meaning of the job can change once a real person is depending on you.

One client conversation brought a different kind of discomfort. Living in New York, Sydney could easily focus on wanting more money and more space, especially around friends earning considerably more. Then she spent time talking with a client who was homeless. The encounter made her reconsider what she already had. The tension between ambition and perspective runs through this episode without resolving into an easy answer.

During an internship in Los Angeles, Sydney also noticed a problem that courtroom advocacy alone could not solve. A man arrived late after biking across the freeway to reach court. She wondered whether a ride could have prevented the difficulty, then wrote a proposal asking Uber to provide transportation vouchers for public defender clients.

Sydney describes getting the proposal accepted, arranging round-trip rides, and passing the project to a nonprofit. Providing a way home mattered too. Clients had jobs, childcare responsibilities, and lives that continued after their appearances. Her story raises a practical question for anyone representing people in difficult circumstances. What is keeping this person from doing what the system expects?

The conversation also moves into Sydney’s experiences at Columbia and Brooklyn Law School. She talks about feeling like an outsider in college, choosing a school partly for its prestige, and finding greater focus once she knew she wanted to pursue public defense. Her father’s example offered another possibility: a lawyer who enjoyed his work and remained an active presence in his children’s lives.

Then there is reality television. Sydney explains how Survivor and The Challenge fit into her education and working life, why she pursued those experiences, and what she believes they taught her about confidence and perception. She connects those lessons to negotiating with prosecutors and being willing to take a case to trial, while emphasizing that the decision belongs to the client.

Neal and Sydney also discuss professional relationships, introducing yourself to judges, and developing a reputation inside the courthouse. Sydney describes wanting her legal career to remain central even as television creates other opportunities. She considers possible futures in public service alongside a very different possibility: stepping back to focus on family.

In a more personal part of the conversation, Sydney discusses her Jewish identity, her support for Israel, and antisemitism she says she experienced at work after October 7. She describes the strain on workplace relationships, her decision to leave her union, and her efforts to remain focused on clients through those disagreements.

The episode closes with Neal’s three questions about looking back, being remembered, and having one more conversation with someone you have lost. Sydney’s answer about her step-grandfather, Grandpa Bob, brings the conversation back to the people we wish could see who we have become.

Subscribe to That One Lawyer Podcast for honest conversations about the people behind the profession, the relationships that shape their careers, and what it takes to build a life alongside the law.

Also Available On
book

Sign up for my newsletter

    Connect with Neal