Podcast

Emma Lilley grew up in Stoke-on-Trent without family connections to the legal profession. She didn’t always feel she belonged in the traditional world of law. And when she chose to move in-house early in her career, she was repeatedly told she was making a mistake.

But Emma discovered something more important than following the conventional path: finding a place where she could be herself, build meaningful relationships, and succeed on her own terms.

She describes sitting in rooms where other students seemed to understand the rules already. They knew about training contracts and the next steps in a legal career. She was starting from zero. The more she learned, the more she wondered whether she had made the wrong decision. A gap year and the discovery that lawyers could work inside businesses changed the direction of her career.

That discovery did not make the criticism disappear. Emma explains the messages she received about choosing in-house work, the assumptions attached to her university and background, and the difficulty of trusting your own judgment when people around you treat a different route as a lesser one. Neal and Emma also explore why private practice can be the right fit for other lawyers, depending on their interests, the work they want to do, and the mentorship they need.

The conversation begins with an unexpected encounter in Starbucks. Before a legal advocacy exam, a nervous Emma approached comedian Jimmy Carr for confidence advice. He invited her to sit down. She shares what that conversation taught her about preparation, presence, and asking for help when you are struggling, even when the person you ask is a stranger.

For anyone considering an in-house counsel role, Emma describes the breadth of the work, including commercial contracts, data protection, corporate matters, and employment issues. She talks about the appeal of smaller teams, collaboration across a business, and knowing when to bring in someone with deeper expertise. Her experience challenges the assumption that there is only one credible way to begin a legal career.
Neal and Emma also discuss artificial intelligence and the future of junior legal jobs. Emma is concerned about what happens to training when technology takes over work that once gave new lawyers their first opportunities to learn. She also sees possibilities for people who can identify the problems legal teams are facing and help solve them. The discussion turns to judgment, education, and how young lawyers can find a way into a changing profession.

Relationships run through the entire episode. Emma remembers the legal director who took a chance on her before she had finished her degree and the lecturer who continued to support her. Those people mattered when the work of pushing for change became exhausting. Neal connects that experience to the people who open doors, offer encouragement, and help us keep going before we can fully see our own potential.

Emma explains how her In-house Potter community helped support her campaign for regional solicitor admission ceremonies outside London. What might sound like an administrative change becomes deeply personal when she talks about the cost of travel, who gets to attend, and the grandfather she wishes could have seen her qualify.
She also shares why she created InHOCO, a free careers resource for people exploring in-house law. The questions she once struggled to answer now shape the information she wants others to have access to, from finding a first role to understanding the skills a lawyer needs inside a business.

Later, Emma challenges the language of soft skills. She sees communication, collaboration, and the ability to understand other people as human skills that contribute to how a business works. She and Neal discuss what lawyers can offer beyond technical answers and how relationships affect both professional fulfillment and the bottom line.

The episode closes with Emma reflecting on a recent career decision, time with her young son, what she would tell her younger self, and the conversation she wishes she could have with her grandfather.

Connect with Emma Lilley on LinkedIn, find her on Instagram at @emmalilleylaw, and explore her work through In-house Potter and InHOCO.

If you have ever questioned whether your background, accent, university, or career choices belong in law, this conversation offers a perspective from someone who has faced those questions herself.
Subscribe to That One Lawyer Podcast for honest conversations with lawyers about relationships, identity, resilience, and the human experiences behind their careers.